Triangle effect and the connotative meaning of trust in prisoner's dilemma: a cross cultural study
Abstract
Two hundred and forty-nine male postgraduate students of management played the
Prisoner’s Dilemma Game (Deutsch 1960) and filled out a postgame questionnaire measuring
attitude toward the ‘other player’. Striking differences resulted between trusting
and trustworthy subjects on the one hand and suspicious and untrustworthy subjects on
the other with respect to different meanings given to the dimension of trust (cooperation)
in the interaction. As predicted, trusting behavior of the other player was given a
positive evaluative meaning - good versus bad - by the trusting and trustworthy subjects
and negative dynamism meaning - weak versus strong - by the suspicious and
untrustworthy subjects. The trusting players expected the typical other to make either
trusting or suspicious moves, whereas the suspicious subjects expected the typical other
to be uniformly suspicious, yielding a high Triangularity Index (Kelley and Stahelski
1970). Most provocatively-, while 51% of trusting subjects thought that the other player
was a female, 81% from among the suspicious subjects thought so. Some implications of
the results in interpersonal and organizational situations are discussed.
Collections
- Journal Articles [3698]